Untitled Document

Lancaster Newspapers Newspaper In Education Week
Judging Form
WRITER'S CHOICE & NEWS FEATURE

Student Name: ____________________________

Category: ________________________________


Judge Instructions: Determine the level of the entry by matching the description with the entry,

Enter the deserving number of points (out of a possible 4) in the score box to the right.

Total Score:

 

 

4
3
2
1
  • Clear, distinct controlling point
  • 5 W’s present
  • Active verbs, strong adjectives
  • Informs, educates and/or entertains
  • Substantial, relevant content
  • Well-chosen details
  • “Inverted Pyramid” style (most important details first)
  • Consistent and effective tone
  • Thorough control of sentence formation
  • Few errors in spelling, grammar and punctuation which do not interfere with meaning
  • Clear controlling point
  • 5 W’s evident
  • Well-chosen verbs and adjectives
  • Informs, educates and/or entertains
  • Adequate content
  • Well-chosen details
  • Logical order and transitions
  • Consistent tone
  • Adequate control of sentence formation
  • Some errors in spelling, grammar and punctuation with little interference in meaning
  • Vague controlling point
  • 5 W’s missing or vague
  • Weak verbs and adjectives
  • Inadequate content
  • Underdeveloped or repetitive elaboration
  • Inconsistent or distracting organization
  • Limited diversity of language
  • Inconsistent control of sentence formation
  • Many errors in spelling, grammar and punctuation with some interference with meaning
  • Little or no evidence of a controlling point
  • 5 W’s missing
  • Superficial, underdeveloped writing with little or no supporting details
  • Little or no evidence of organizational strategies or structure
  • Inconsistent tone
  • Minimal control of sentence formation
  • Many errors in spelling, grammar and punctuation which interfere with meaning